for those of you who have been living under a rock for the last few weeks, google has just released a [surprise! beta!] service called google voice. google voice, essentially, is a free online service attempting to solve common problems that the current phone system has (for example, i have 3 phones and 7 SIM cards, and depending on my location, use only 2).
a few of the great features include:
all told, this sounds really awesome. i was lucky enough to get an invite, and set it up and everything. once i get some more time to configure, i'll send you all my new number.
it makes me a bit nervous though.
i love google. i really do. (though i'd never judge anyone who works as a genius at yahoo!.) but i can't help but think that google's mission statement "don't be evil" may be evolving slowly. they have more data about me than any other company in the world. generally speaking, that's never been a problem before, because they use the data only to make my online experience better (which it certainly does). i can't remember the last time i clicked on an ad that wasn't one of google's suggestions. and google's suggestions are often not bad ones. in fact, they're really just search results that are kicked a bit higher up the list because they paid for it (and google makes that clear).
and gmail reads through my email to figure out what the message is about and advertises accordingly. for example, sending an email to my mom about an upcoming trip to chicago mentions airfare, hotels, and good pizza places. that's useful. and it doesn't bother me if i don't use it. and i trust that no human will ever read that email.
but this voice thing may be crossing a line. just a little. if they start to store my voicemails, and transcribe them into text, i can't help but think that i'm giving a lot of data about my personal life. of course now it's no problem; but yahoo! caved, and aol caved, and microsoft caved, when the government required that they give them their search result data (google did not). but who knows what will happen in the future. as google's mission statement becomes more flexible, and they become more like microsoft, will i regret giving google all of my voicemails and call history?
i'm going to the states soon, which will be a perfect time to set this up and use it. but i can't decide. what do you guys think? am i crazy? or am i just starting to realize how much of me is located in google's servers?
comments
Will
[28 July 2009]I have long wondered why hippies distrust every corporation taking their information unless it's Google. Having voicemail is a pretty creepy step. And as good an effective as online behavioral advertising might be, it still means they have the potential to do whatever they want with the information they have. If there's chance of them transcribing your voicemails, I wouldn't do it.
Benji!
[28 July 2009]I think you are both being silly. What do you think they are going to do with your voicemail?
If you are scared of people knowing about what you do online then you can't really be online. The web is inherently pretty insecure.
THE Lowly Peon
[29 July 2009]I think I'm gonna do it. but will probably hold some information back for a while til I can feel it out.
though AT&T apparently forced apple to reject google's native voice app for the iPhone. that would have sealed the deal.
THE Lowly Peon
[21 August 2009]WJerome: check this out. google isn't always in charge: http://www.loopinsight.com/2009/08/20/model-forces-google-to-reveal-identity-of-offensive-blogger/
THE Lowly Peon
[21 August 2009](and that was just because of some rude comments. imagine if someone really needs to see it)
Will
[21 August 2009]thelowlypeon: Whoa.
THE Lowly Peon
[26 August 2009]WJerome: an update to the story where the model sued google (and win) to see who was criticizing her is on slashdot here. shedropped the suit. what bothers me about this is that she used the legal system to out someone's annonimity, and then dropped it. I firmly believe that anyone should be given the right and ability to be annonymous on the Internet if they choose to be.
THE Lowly Peon
[25 September 2009]According to the onion, you can opt out of google's services by living in the google opt out village
THE Lowly Peon
[19 October 2009]bentomas: anything is possible
(via saulemander)
THE Lowly Peon
[27 October 2009]yet another update regarding that above mentioned trial where google willingly gave up a client's information and — worse — disable his account, because a bank goofed up big time and sent an email to the wring address:
http://citizenvox.org/2009/10/21/in-google-we-trust-think-again/
I know google is awesome. but the whole thing is really that someone has this information.
(note that I have been using my google voice number and am quite pleased)
via daring fireball